There are not many foods that herald back to the joys of our youth quite like a warm, gooey grilled cheese sandwich. Just imagining the crusty bread, artisan dairy, and aromatic flavors can quickly get you hungry for lunch. Cranberry Country Market in Tomah, WI, prides itself on its organic, farm fresh ingredients, and their staff is sharing the secret to making the ultimate grilled cheese using the freshest items from their country store.

How to Make the Ultimate Grilled Cheese

1. The Bread

The slices of bread are your building blocks for the best grilled cheese sandwich. You should choose a hearty variety, but steer clear from anything with too much flavor such as a rye or pumpernickel. With a grilled cheese, you want the flavors of the cheese to shine through while the bread plays a supporting role. Cranberry Country Market offers a variety of loaves and also sells delicious farm-fresh butter, which you will need to slather your slices before putting them on the grill.

2. The Cheese

Artisan grilled cheese makers will argue over the best cheese to use, from Gruyere to cheddar, so the flavor combinations are really up to the digression of the chef. Some even recommend adding fresh fruit such as crisp green apple slices or deli meat like honey turkey to add a bit of sweetness and break up the oiliness from the cheese and butter. 

3. The Toppings & Sides

There’s no harm with a little salt and pepper, but the ultimate grilled cheese is elevated with a sharp or grainy mustard and some fresh produce like a few slices of grilled tomato or a crisp leaf of romaine. Once you’ve created your masterpiece, top it off with a little paprika, oregano, or even cayenne for a spicy kick. Pair it with a briny dill pickle or a piping hot bowl of tomato soup for the perfect lunch combo.

Making the best grilled cheese ultimately come down to the quality ingredients you use. For a great local grocery experience with fresh ingredients, Cranberry Country Market has exatly what you’re looking for. Check out their delicious baked goods or their wide selection of fresh produce and fruit on their website, or give them a call at (608) 374-4944. You can also connect with the store on Facebook.